Does Handwriting Without Tears help autistic children write?
A handwriting program used in schools and therapy, tested in only a handful of small studies with autistic children. Here’s what 13 sources can and can’t tell you.
Research synthesisUpdated 2026-10-0213 sources includedProtocol v4.5 (Amdt. v4.6)
Handwriting Without TearsNot enough research yet — only one comparison study, and it hasn’t been checked by other experts
A care note before you read. “Not enough research” does not mean the program does not work. It means it has not been tested well enough to know. If writing is hard for your child, your child’s occupational therapist or school team can talk with you about it.
Key Takeaways
Only a few studies have tested this program with autistic children. The biggest is a student’s master’s project that other experts have not checked. The others had just 1 or 2 children.
The student project found the program group improved more. It had 36 children aged 5 to 12 at a school for autistic children in Doha, Qatar. Half used the program 20 minutes a day for about three months; half had their usual lessons. Both groups got better, and the program group got better by more on a checklist of letter and shape skills.
That project did not give each group’s scores. The one math test it reported seems to look at one group’s before-and-after change, not at the difference between the two groups (this is our own check). Two tiny preschool studies also reported gains, but one had 2 children and the other had 1 boy who might have autism.
If your child mouths small objects, ask how materials are chosen and watched. In the school study, the writer saw many children put short crayons, small pencils and wooden sticks in their mouths and wrote that this “could have been hazardous.” No study measured harms on purpose.
If you are thinking about it, it is reasonable to ask what goal it is working on, how progress will be checked, how long it will take, and how it fits with other ways your child can write, such as typing.
What this means for you
Handwriting Without Tears is a handwriting program that schools and therapists can buy, made by occupational therapists. Only a few studies have tried it with autistic children. The largest is a student’s master’s project of 36 children. The program group improved more, but no one else has checked the work, and it did not report each group’s scores.
The other autism studies had 1 or 2 children. We found nothing on writing speed or school results, and no study followed children for long. It does not mean the program fails. It means we cannot say yet.
“Not enough research” is not the same as “it doesn’t work.” It means this program has not been tested well enough, with autistic children, to know.
Who was studied. Autistic children from preschool age to 12: 36 children aged 5 to 12 at a school for autistic children in Doha, Qatar, plus two very small preschool studies. For most studies we read only a short summary, not the full paper. Whether the results apply to any particular child is not established.
A safety note. The writer of the Doha school study saw many children put small program items in their mouths, such as short crayons, small pencils and wooden sticks, and wrote that this “could have been hazardous.” Some children who are bothered by movement or sound also found the action songs hard. This was an observation in one school, not a measured harm. If your child mouths small objects, it is reasonable to ask how materials are chosen and watched.
Where the studies landed
Not enough research yet
Only the first three studies below are about autistic children. Most of the rest is about children who are not autistic, and we did not count it as proof for autistic children.
3 Autism studies: gains reported, but tiny or unchecked
9 Not autism-specific: one review and small studies in other children
1 No better than other programs (children who are not autistic)
Tap the cover to open it. Seven more sources are in the record but not shown as covers: the company’s two pages, one paper that only uses the program’s checklist, and four we could not open.
One studyReview of many studies
Tap any tile to read it. Seven more sources are in the record but not shown as tiles: the company’s two pages, one paper that only uses the program’s checklist, and four we could not open.
Autism studies: gains reported, but tiny or unchecked3
The largest is a student’s master’s project (Majeed 2023) with 36 autistic children in Doha, Qatar. Both groups improved and the program group improved more on a checklist, but other experts have not checked it, and it gave no group scores. Two tiny preschool studies reported gains: one with 2 children with autism or other delays learning 4 letters (Carlson 2009), and one with 1 boy who might have autism learning to write his name (Steele 2015). We read only summaries of those two.
Not autism-specific: one review and small studies in other children9
A 2026 review of 28 studies on teaching autistic children handwriting and spelling said programs made for all children “may benefit some autistic children.” We could not see which studies it included. Eight small studies tried the program with children who are not autistic: preschoolers with developmental delay, children with intellectual disability or Down syndrome, and kindergarten and first-grade classes. Most reported gains, but they had no comparison group or followed only 1 to 3 children, so ordinary teaching and growing up could explain the gains. We did not count them as proof for autistic children.
No better than other programs (children who are not autistic)1
In one study of 50 third graders learning joined-up (cursive) writing, the program did no better than two other programs. All the children improved. This is not about autistic children, so we did not read it in either direction for them.
Spectrum Connect reviews published research on interventions parents are exploring for their autistic children — so you can see where the evidence actually stands. No agenda, no selling, no cherry-picking. Just the studies, our method, and what it means for you.
See the research behind thisFor anyone who wants to check our work · 13 sources
01
Where we looked
This run was a web-based scoping search, not a full search of the research databases: 2 web searches plus 10 page-fetch attempts, 5 of which could be read, including one query to the ERIC education database. No bibliographic database was searched directly beyond that one query, so there are no per-database counts, and no protocol was registered in advance. PubMed and PMC could not be used, and one citation lookup was rate-limited twice. A full run would cover PubMed/MEDLINE, Embase, APA PsycINFO, CINAHL, ERIC, OTseeker, the Cochrane Library, Epistemonikos, ProQuest Dissertations & Theses, program ratings sites (What Works Clearinghouse, Evidence for ESSA) and trial registers. Here is the PubMed search of record.
("Handwriting Without Tears"[tiab] OR "Learning Without Tears"[tiab] OR "Get Set for School"[tiab] OR "gray block paper"[tiab] OR "Print Tool"[tiab] OR "Screener of Handwriting Proficiency"[tiab]) AND ("Handwriting"[MeSH] OR handwrit*[tiab] OR "letter formation"[tiab] OR legib*[tiab] OR "Child"[MeSH] OR "Autism Spectrum Disorder"[MeSH] OR autis*[tiab])Run on PubMed →
02
What we did with what we found
32records surfaced (18 web results + 14 ERIC records)
−8duplicates
24unique works, plus 3 reached through the company’s own pages
−7not selected (two student papers, a thesis-database record, an earlier review, an assessment paper, two autism resource pages)
20cited as sources: 16 opened, 4 not opened
Records were not formally screened; we judged them by title and by the abstract shown in the ERIC index. Of the 20, 13 are shown as tiles. The other 7 are the company’s two pages, one paper that only uses the program’s checklist as a measure, and four we could not open (a Johns Hopkins study the company cites, a journal article on school use, a study by Roberts and colleagues, and an adapted-program study in a special education setting).
03
What the strongest evidence says
Forming letters and writing neatly
One student project and two tiny studies report gains. The student project was not checked by other experts and gave no group scores.
How sure
Very low
Early skills, like drawing lines and shapes
Only the student project checked this, with the same limits.
How sure
Very low
Writing speed, and results at school
No studies with autistic children. A few looked at speed or spelling, but only in children who are not autistic.
How sure
No data
Does it work for children who are not autistic?
Mixed. One fair-sized study found no difference from other programs; the rest were small with no comparison group. Kept separate and not counted for autistic children.
How sure
Very low
Harms
No study measured harms on purpose. The school study noted children mouthing small program materials.
How sure
Not measured
Ray Kawai · Protocol v4.5BCAT · Open record
Spectrum Connect is not a medical provider, and nothing here is medical advice. This page shows where the research stands and how we got there. It is not a recommendation, and it is not a substitute for your child’s doctor or care team. What you do with it is yours to decide, together with them.
Think we got something wrong?Report a factual error
We publish the whole record so it can be checked, and that only counts if we act on what you find. If a number looks wrong, a study is missing or has been retracted, or we’ve read a finding in a way the evidence doesn’t support, tell us.
You don’t need a research background to file one. “This doesn’t match what our doctor told us” is a useful report. Every one reaches a person: we reply within seven days, and within thirty we have either corrected the page or told you when we will. Substantive reports send the affected steps back through the protocol and need fresh sign-off before anything here changes.
Are you a clinician or researcher?Review this article
If you have read this and the evidence holds up, you can sign off on it. We send you a personal review link where you confirm your credentials, and our team checks every review before anything is published. Once approved, your name and a link to your profile appear on this article.
The full record for Handwriting Without Tears, open for anyone who wants to check our work.
Who does each step
A research agent does the mechanical and drafting work. A person checks it. A named reviewer signs it before anything is published. code automatic · agent AI draft a human verifies · human a named person decides.
01
Define humanquestion + outcomes
Does Handwriting Without Tears (also sold as Learning Without Tears, including its Get Set for School preschool version) improve outcomes for autistic children? Outcomes: letter formation and legibility; handwriting speed; early skills such as pre-writing strokes, shapes and name writing; school and daily-life results such as spelling and written work; harms and burden. Children who are not autistic (general education; other disabilities such as developmental delay, intellectual disability and Down syndrome) are graded as separate groups and never credited to autism. Scope: this page covers the named program only. The separate Handwriting / Fine Motor report covers handwriting and fine-motor programs in general; its class-level evidence and its CO-OP evidence are not transferred here. Protocol v4.5 + Amendment v4.6 Rev C, Track B (no adequate systematic review; one unpublished student trial, plus single-case and uncontrolled studies).
02
Register humanPROSPERO + OSF
Prospective registration (R1) not filed for this run. Logged as a deviation.
03
Search codedatabases
Web-based scoping only: 2 web searches + 10 page-fetch attempts (5 read, including one ERIC query that returned 14 records). Five attempts failed: a citation lookup was rate-limited twice, a journal page redirected, one publisher page showed a CAPTCHA, and the company’s link to its Johns Hopkins study is blocked to automated tools. PubMed and PMC were not used (CAPTCHA). No database was searched directly beyond the one ERIC query, which is not counted as a database search. Search of record stated above; per-database counts PENDING.
3.5
Intake checks codestanding + retraction
16 of 20 sources opened: 1 read in full text (the 2023 student project), 2 company pages, and 13 judged from ERIC abstracts; text in quotation marks is verbatim from those. 4 not opened (Johns Hopkins study, a journal article on school use, Roberts and colleagues, an adapted-program study). A retraction check is not applicable to the student project; checks for the other sources are not recorded.
04
Screen agenthumantwo reviewers
Judged by title and abstract, one reviewer, no dual screening. 7 works not selected: two student repository PDFs, a thesis-database record, an earlier narrative review (read for the separate Fine Motor report), an assessment-validity paper, and two autism resource pages.
Gate A
Eligible and in scope? Yes, with flags — in two autism studies the participants’ diagnosis is uncertain (“autism or developmental delays”; “suspected autism spectrum disorder”), and several studies used parts of the program or an adapted version rather than the curriculum as sold.
05
Appraise agenthumanAMSTAR 2 / RoB 2
AMSTAR 2 for the 2026 scoping review (abstract only, provisional): Critically Low. RoB 2 for the 2023 student project (from a summary of its full text, provisional): High — “randomly split” with no method stated, teacher-delivered and unblinded with both groups drawn from the same five classes, attendance problems and a term cut short by 1.5 months, and no group results. Statistics check (inferred): the reported t = 4.609772, p = .00025 fits a test on 18 children, such as one group’s before-and-after, not a 36-child comparison between groups. Research-integrity screen triggered: not peer reviewed, no registration, no baseline table. The 2009 three-program study’s allocation method was not captured, so it is not rated. Uncontrolled studies have no comparison group, so their gains are treated as confounded by growth and ordinary teaching. Single-case ratings PENDING.
06
Map overlap agentcodeshared trials
Whether the 2026 scoping review includes the 2023 student project or the two preschool studies is PENDING; if it does, they are one line of evidence, not two. One author is on four of the single-case studies here (one research group). The student project and a 2013 single-case study were also found for the separate Fine Motor report; both were looked up again here, not copied.
Gate B
Overlap resolved? Flag. The 2026 review likely includes some of these autism studies (inclusion PENDING), and one lab wrote four of the single-case studies.
07
Synthesize agenthumanper outcome
Autistic children — letter formation and early skills: gains in one unchecked student project and two tiny single-case studies. Speed and school results: nothing found. Children who are not autistic: reported separately and never credited to autism.
Gate C
Strongest sources agree? No review disagreement — no review of moderate or higher quality exists. The company says the program is “proven effective” and meets the US “Tier 2” evidence level, but the one study it cites for that could not be opened. Of the 8 items on its evidence list, 1 claims to test the program and 7 are about handwriting in general, teachers’ beliefs, or use the program’s checklist; none mentions autism. That sits beside a no-difference result in a three-program comparison (children who are not autistic): a gap between promotion and evidence, not a disagreement among reviews.
Gate C′
Harm checked first: no harms measured. The Doha school study reports many children mouthing small program materials (“could have been hazardous”) and some children finding the action songs hard because of movement or sound sensitivity. Treated as a materials-and-setting hazard shown as a parent-facing safety note, not as a measured harm.
08
Rate certainty agenthumanGRADE
Autistic children — letter formation and early skills: Very Low (starts High because the student project says groups were “randomly split”; −2 risk of bias, −2 imprecision, −1 unpublished, no group estimates). Speed and school results: no evidence captured. Children who are not autistic and children with other disabilities: graded in their own groups, all Very Low, and not transferred to autism.
Gate D
Sign-off — the independent clinical reviewer role is open.Lead verifier: Ray Kawai, BCAT. The search and appraisal limits recorded in steps 2–5 stand as stated.
09
Set readout codedecision table
Every autism outcome (letter formation, early skills, speed, school results) routes to Row 7, “Not supported: not enough research yet.” The groups of children who are not autistic also route to Row 7 and are not transferred. The company’s evidence-tier claim and the Fine Motor report’s class-level evidence are not mapped.
10
Translate agenthumanplain language
Written for a tired parent: separates “not enough research” from “doesn’t work,” reports the mouthing observation as a plain safety note, and reports the statistics check as our own inference. The company’s evidence-tier claim is reported as unchecked, not as evidence.
11
Publish codeopen record
Published 2026-10-02.
Gate E
Living surveillance. First update triggers: getting the Johns Hopkins efficacy study (design, population, effect sizes, and whether autistic students were included) and the 2026 review’s list of included studies. Key gap: a peer-reviewed comparison of the program with autistic children using an independent measure of legibility and speed, a school outcome, and harms monitoring.
The people accountable
RK
Lead synthesizer & lead verifier · steps 1, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10 · Gate D
Why only named people are shown. We do not display experts we do not have. Everyone listed here is accountable for this page.
Autism studies: gains reported, but tiny or uncheckedStudent master’s project · described as randomized · n=36 · not peer reviewed
The effectiveness of Handwriting Without Tears programme in teaching handwriting to students on the autism spectrum
Majeed SA · Master’s project, SUNY Buffalo State University, May 2023
What it looked at
36 Qatari children aged 5 to 12 in five classes at a school for autistic children in Doha. The children were “randomly split into two groups”: one used the program 20 minutes a day for three months, the other had “traditional methods.” Outcome: competency checklists (who made them is not stated).
What it found
Both groups improved. The program group “exhibited greater difference between pre-test and post-test scores and mastered more competency levels.” No group averages, spreads or effect sizes were reported. The one test reported (t = 4.609772, p = .00025) fits a test on 18 children, such as one group’s before-and-after, rather than a comparison of 36 (our own check; the comparison is not stated). The writer also noted children mouthing small program items, and a term cut short by about 1.5 months with attendance problems.
Quality — our provisional read
High risk of bias (provisional). No method given for the random split, teacher-delivered and unblinded with both groups in the same classes, missing data not reported, no group results. Not peer reviewed and not registered. Read in full text via a summary.
Autism studies: gains reported, but tiny or uncheckedSingle-case (multiple baseline) · n=2
Teaching preschool children with autism and developmental delays to write
Carlson B, McLaughlin TF, Derby KM, Blecher J · Electronic Journal of Research in Educational Psychology, 2009
What it looked at
Two preschool children with autism or developmental delays (which child had which was not captured), learning to write 4 letters with the program’s chalkboard and worksheet plus a highlight, a model and a start point.
What it found
At the start, neither child could legibly write the target letters. Writing increased for both. No numbers were captured from the abstract.
Quality — our provisional read
Not rated yet (single-case ratings pending). Two children only; used parts of the program plus extra teaching steps, not the curriculum as sold. Same research group as three other single-case studies here. Abstract only.
Autism studies: gains reported, but tiny or uncheckedSingle-case · n=1
Employing Handwriting without Tears® to teach a 4-year-old preschool student to write his name with the appropriate size, shape, and form combined with an imitate/trace/copy/memory procedure
Steele EC, McLaughlin T, Derby KM, Weber KP, Donica DK, McKenzie M · Journal on Educational Psychology, 2015
What it looked at
One 4-year-old preschool boy with suspected autism spectrum disorder, learning to write his name using the program’s Get Set for School materials together with an imitate, trace, copy and memory routine.
What it found
His independent name writing improved. No numbers were captured from the abstract.
Quality — our provisional read
Not rated yet (single-case ratings pending). One child, and autism was only suspected. The program was combined with another teaching routine, so its part cannot be separated out. Same research group as three other studies here. Abstract only.
Not autism-specificScoping review · 28 studies · handwriting and spelling instruction
A scoping review of transcription instruction involving children with autism
Bailey B, Philpott-Robinson K, Ray K · Journal of Research in Reading, 2026
What it looked at
Instruction in transcription (handwriting and spelling) for autistic children: 4,859 records identified, 28 studies included (14 on handwriting, 9 on spelling, 4 on how instruction is delivered, 1 on autistic children’s experiences).
What it found
Programs built for all children “may benefit some autistic children.” We could not see which studies it included, so we do not know whether it counts any of the studies on this page.
Quality — our provisional read
Provisional AMSTAR 2 (abstract only): Critically Low. Most checks could not be assessed without the full text. A scoping review maps research and does not combine results.
Not autism-specificBefore-and-after · 2 classes · no comparison group
Collaborative instruction and Handwriting without Tears®: a strong foundation for kindergarten learning
Randall BS · Journal of Occupational Therapy, Schools & Early Intervention, 2018
What it looked at
Two kindergarten classes taught with the program, measured with The Print Tool, an instrument that belongs to the program. Not about autistic children.
What it found
The author reports “statistically and clinically significant gains.”
Quality — our provisional read
No comparison group, so gains cannot be separated from ordinary teaching and growth, and the measure belongs to the program. Abstract only.
Not autism-specificBefore-and-after · n=15 · 4 weeks · no comparison group
Does participating in a daily Handwriting without Tears curriculum for 4-weeks improve a first-grade student’s spelling abilities: one group pre- and post-test design
Tallas A, Cole A · Journal of Occupational Therapy, Schools & Early Intervention, 2025
What it looked at
15 first graders using the program daily for 4 weeks, with spelling as the outcome. Not about autistic children.
What it found
Spelling improved by an average of 5.27 words, and 14 of the 15 children improved.
Quality — our provisional read
No comparison group, so gains cannot be separated from ordinary teaching and growth. Abstract only.
Not autism-specificCase series · delivered by video · no comparison group
Handwriting intervention effectiveness via telehealth delivery
Bray LMP, Skubik-Peplaski C, Schneck C, Thrash C, Domino C · Journal of Occupational Therapy, Schools & Early Intervention, 2024
What it looked at
The program delivered by video to children with handwriting or spelling difficulties. Not about autistic children. The number of children was not captured.
What it found
Speed gains were significant. Changes in writing quality and spelling were not significant.
Quality — our provisional read
No comparison group, so gains cannot be separated from ordinary teaching and growth. Abstract only.
The differential effects of the use of Handwriting without Tears® modified gray block paper to teach two preschool students with developmental delays capital letter writing skills
Griffith J, McLaughlin TF, Neyman J, Donica DK, Robison M · Journal on Educational Psychology, 2013
What it looked at
Two preschool children with developmental delays learning to write capital letters, using the program’s modified gray block paper. Not about autistic children.
What it found
We did not capture its numbers from the summary we saw.
Quality — our provisional read
Not rated yet (single-case ratings pending). Tests one component (the paper), not the whole program. Same research group as three other single-case studies here.
The effects of “Handwriting without Tears®” on the handwriting skills of appropriate size, form, and tool for a four year-old boy with a developmental delay
Meyers C, McLaughlin TF, Derby M, Weber KP, Robison M · Journal of Special Education Apprenticeship, 2015
What it looked at
One four-year-old boy with a developmental delay, working on letter size, letter form and how he held the writing tool. Not about autistic children.
What it found
We did not capture its numbers from the summary we saw.
Quality — our provisional read
Not rated yet (single-case ratings pending). One child. Same research group as three other single-case studies here.
No better than other programs (children who are not autistic)Three-program comparison · n=50 · allocation not captured
Comparison of cursive handwriting instruction programs among students without identified problems
Shimel K, Candler C, Neville-Smith M · Physical & Occupational Therapy in Pediatrics, 2009
What it looked at
50 third graders without identified problems learning cursive for 10 to 15 minutes a day for 6 weeks with Handwriting Without Tears, with Loops and Other Groups, or by continuing with Zaner-Bloser. Not about autistic children.
What it found
All the children improved, and there were no significant differences between programs at the end.
Quality — our provisional read
Not rated. How children were assigned to programs was not captured, so we cannot tell whether it was random. Abstract only. Shown here because it is the only fair-sized comparison of the program that we found.